The Plans You Never Threw Out

The Setting Down · Episode 02

The Setting Down · Episode 02

The Plans You Never Threw Out

On the plans we once made for a life that unfolded differently.

November 17, 2026Audio essay
A cardboard keepsake box left on a wire shelf inside an otherwise empty closet

About This Piece

There are things we hold on to long after the future we imagined for them has changed.

Sometimes they stay in a box, on a shelf, or tucked somewhere in a closet. We don’t necessarily need to throw them away.

Transcript

Read the transcript

Every time you pack up and move, there's a shoebox you bring with you.

You know the one. It goes in the back of a closet in the new place. You don't open it.

Then three years later, you move again. And there it is.

You pick it up. You feel the weight of it. You know exactly what's inside.

And no— it's not shoes.

You put it in the U-Haul. Again.

Mine's a Nike box that's real heavy.

Maybe yours is one of those clear plastic totes full of papers you haven’t looked at in years. Maybe it’s a binder from a class you took back in college. Maybe it’s a box of merchandise left over from a business you started a while back and never quite figured out what to do with.

Maybe it’s a new business plan with a name on the front that you came up with at two in the morning... and then talked about with anybody willing to listen.

Three years later, you still haven’t found the time—or the space—to do anything with it.

Maybe it’s not even something you can put in a box.

Maybe it’s the name you once picked out for a child you thought you’d have by now.

Or the family you pictured around them with the dog and picket fence.

And here's what's strange. You don't go through it.

Twelve years and you've never once sat down on the floor of that closet and opened the whole thing up.

But you know where it is. If I asked you to go get it right now... you could probably find it in four minutes.

You don't look at it. But you don't throw it away either.

I've thought about that.

Why keep something you don't use, don't look at, and probably haven't needed in years?

And I don't think it's because we still believe everything in that box is going to happen. Some of it clearly isn't.

I think it might be harder to look because you know the person who put it there.

You know what they wanted.

And you know how they felt when they said what they wanted. It was real.

And for them... it wasn't some plan.

It was next.

I wanted to be a psychologist.

For a long time, that's what I thought I would do.

I've always had this thing about people. I want to understand them.

Why somebody made the decision they made. Why two people can go through something similar... and somehow come out of it differently.

I love to people-watch. Listen to them. Watch how they move, their faces, their hands. Try to understand what's underneath what they're saying.

And I wanted to help people in a way that was actually useful to them.

So when I pictured my life... being a psychologist was in it.

And I can still recognize the person who wanted that.

I understand him. Some of him is still here.

I just didn't become a psychologist.

Life went another way.

When Katrina hit New Orleans in 2005—

it shifted a lot for me. And I don't think I understood then how much of my life I was going to have to adjust because of it.

I just kept going.

And eventually, I started building another version. Then another.

Until at some point, I had to stop measuring the person I became against the person I thought I was supposed to become... and actually get to know the person who was here.

That's different.

Because I don't think the younger version of me was wrong.

He just hadn't lived yet.

When you're young, people tell you that you can be anything.

And you believe them.

Why wouldn't you? Life hasn't given you much evidence yet.

You can see the thing you want clearly. The goal feels real — almost too real. Like there's nothing you couldn't do.

There's nothing between you and it yet.

No hurricane. No job you didn't know you'd take. No person you haven't met. No responsibility you don't have yet. No version of yourself you haven't become.

The goal is still free enough that you can see it.

And then you live.

That's it. You live.

Things happen. Some of them you choose. Some of them you don't.

You change your mind about things you were sure about. You find things you didn't know you wanted. You lose things you thought would always be there.

And somewhere in all of that... the plan changes.

Maybe once. Maybe twenty times.

Until one day you look around and realize— you've built a life.

It's just not that one.

And that doesn't mean this life is bad.

Maybe you like this life. Maybe there are parts of it you're proud of.

People you wouldn't trade. Things that make you happy.

That doesn't mean you have to pretend you never wanted the other one.

I think sometimes we believe those two things can't sit next to each other.

That if I'm happy here... I shouldn't feel anything about there.

But I don't know if that's true.

Maybe you can love parts of the person you've become... and still remember the person you thought you'd be.

Maybe one doesn't have to make the other wrong.

Maybe that's why it's hard to look in the box.

Because you know that person. You know what they wanted.

And you know something they don't know yet.

You know what happens.

You know which parts of the plan survive. Which parts change. Which parts never happen at all.

And you also know something they couldn't have known.

There's going to be another life.

Not the one they drew.

This one.

Maybe that's why the box keeps moving with us.

Not because we're waiting for everything inside it to come true.

Maybe we just don't need to throw away every version of ourselves we no longer became.

So the box moves. From one closet to another. One house to another.

One version of you... to the next.

I'm not going to ask you to throw anything out.

I'm not even going to ask you to open it.

Just let yourself remember that it's there. And maybe... who you were when you put it there.

Not what they got wrong. Not everything they didn't know yet.

Just what they wanted.

Because they were allowed to want it.

Even if you don't anymore. Even if it never happened.

You don't have to make that version of you foolish... just because you know more than they did.

You can keep the box.

Nobody said you had to let it go.

A song from this piece

You Can Keep the Box

A companion song to The Plans You Never Threw Out. Scheduled for November 20, 2026.

Next
Next

The Story You've Told Forty Times