The Setting Down · Episode 01
The Setting Down · Episode 01
The Story You’ve Told Forty Times
On the stories we have told so often that we know exactly where people will laugh.
About This Piece
There’s probably a story you’ve told enough times that you know exactly where people will laugh.
The telling can become familiar, even as our relationship to what happened changes.
Transcript
Read the transcript
You've got a story. Everybody's got one.
The job that went bad. The relationship. The thing your family did years ago that everybody agreed never to bring up—which means it comes up constantly.
And you've told it. Not once. A lot.
At dinners. On second dates. To a coworker who asked a simple question and somehow got eleven minutes of random, unsolicited tea.
Here's what I want you to notice about the fortieth time you tell a story.
It's good now.
Maybe a little too good.
There's a part where you slow down. A part where you do the other person's voice. And one particular detail—you know the one—that gets a reaction every single time.
You know where the laugh is. You know where to pause before you say the thing.
You've got timing now.
And you didn't sit down and decide to do that. It just happened.
The way a path gets worn across a lawn. You walk through it once. Then again. And after a while, you start taking the same way through.
The same details. The same pauses. The same places people always react.
Some parts landed, so the next time, you stayed with those a little longer. Some parts didn't, so you moved through those a little faster.
Not because you're trying to change what happened. You're just telling the story.
And after enough times... it can get hard to tell where the memory ends—and the version you've gotten good at telling begins.
I know because I've done it.
I told a story more times than I care to admit. To people who loved me and knew me before I could talk. And on dates with women who couldn't actually pronounce my last name.
Not to a lot of people. To a few people... a lot of times.
I told it enough that I eventually I had versions. There was the at the end of the day... quick recap.
The two-minute elevator pitch.
And then there was the yeah, I got time today... sit down, let's have a few drinks version.
That was the best one. Because that one would change a little as the drinks spilled.
But whichever version you got, I wasn't making anything up.
Oh nah.
It happened.
I just knew which parts to lead with. Which parts needed a little context. Which parts didn't.
And eventually... I didn't need anybody sitting across from me.
I could tell the story to myself.
That's the thing about a story you've told enough times. Nothing in it has to be false.
You just have to choose.
This happened before that. This part matters. That part takes too long to explain.
You leave out what happened after that because what happened after that complicates it... and the story is already long.
You mention what they did in April. You don't mention what you did in March.
Not because you're hiding March. You'd tell anybody who asked. You stay ready.
But nobody asked. So April stays.
March doesn't.
And after a while, that's just the way you go through it.
April. Then this. Then that. Then the part where you already know what everything meant.
Not because you planned it that way. You've just walked this way before.
Because real life wasn't—first this happened, then this happened, and here's what it meant.
There were ordinary Tuesdays in between. Things you misunderstood. Things they misunderstood. Things you were certain about then that you're less certain about now.
Things you did. Things they did. Things neither of you remembers the same way.
A story can't hold all of that.
Maybe it's not supposed to.
Maybe we need the version we tell.
Maybe that's how we take something that happened over months—or years—and make it small enough to carry into a conversation.
There's nothing wrong with that.
I don't think the problem is that we make stories out of what happened. I think we probably have to.
The problem might be when we've told our version so many times... we forget it is a version.
Not a lie.
A version.
The one where April stayed and March didn't. The one where you know exactly who was wrong. The one where you already know what everything meant.
You've told it enough times that you don't have to think about where you're going anymore. You know the way.
And maybe that's the part worth sitting with.
Not whether the story is true.
But is there anything about what happened... that you've stopped looking at?
You might already know which story this is for you.
And you don't have to do anything with it right now. You don't have to correct the record.
You don't have to decide if you were wrong... or if somebody else deserves all the blame you've given them.
Maybe the story has helped you make sense of something that was difficult to make sense of. You don't have to take that away from yourself.
Just sit beside it for a minute.
Not inside it. Beside it.
If you know the story... just hear the way you tell it.
Where you always start.
The part you always come back to.
The part you move past.
You don't have to change any of it.
Just notice the path it takes.
You've been here before.
It's a good story.
That's the problem.
Letters
Leave your email and I’ll send you the next one.
To show the form here, add a native Squarespace Newsletter Block to this page. The script below moves only that block into this section.